Managing by management indicators: why intuition is no longer enough

Hands of two managers reviewing bar graphs on paper and on a tablet on a desk

It's Friday afternoon and you ask yourself how the week went. Your answer comes from a feeling: there was a lot going on, the phone never stopped, the team looked busy. But when you check the bank account, the number doesn't match that feeling. It happens to a lot of small business owners: they work hard, they stay busy, and they still don't know for sure whether the company is going up or down.

Intuition served you well at the start. When it was just you, or you and two other people, you knew everything that was going on because you saw it with your own eyes. The problem starts when the company grows and you can't be everywhere anymore. From that point on, running the business on intuition is like driving at night with the headlights off.

What a management indicator is

A management indicator is a number that measures the production of a person, a department or the whole company, and that is compared against the same number for the previous period. What matters is not the number on its own, but its direction. Selling 40 services this week doesn't say much by itself. Selling 40 when you sold 55 last week, or when you sold 30, tells you two very different stories.

That's why an indicator is kept on a graph, week after week. The graph shows you the trend: whether the line goes up, goes down or stays flat. And that trend is what tells you what to do.

Some examples of indicators in small businesses in the United States:

  • A restaurant in Miami can measure total sales collected per week and the number of tables served.
  • A dental clinic in Orlando can measure patients seen and treatments accepted.
  • An auto repair shop in Tampa can measure finished vehicles delivered and the amount collected for those repairs.
  • A construction company can measure the value of work completed and delivered to the client each week.
  • A distributor can measure orders shipped complete and on time.

Why intuition falls short

Intuition has three problems once the company grows.

The first is that it gets swayed by whatever happened most recently. If an upset customer came in on Monday, you feel the week was bad even if everything else went well. If you closed a big sale on Thursday, you feel everything is going great even if the rest of the month was slow.

The second is that it gets swayed by opinions. An employee who complains a lot can look like the one who works the hardest. A quiet one can look like they don't contribute, when in fact they're holding up half the business. Without numbers, whoever talks loudest wins the argument.

The third is that it comes too late. By the time you finally sense something is wrong, it has usually been wrong for weeks. A graph would have shown you by the second week.

Managing by indicators doesn't mean you stop using your experience. It means your experience works on real data, not on rumors, complaints or fatigue.

What a company run by indicators looks like

In a company that manages by indicators, very concrete things happen. Every position has at least one number that measures its production. Every week, on the same day, each person turns in their number. The numbers are put on graphs, and the graphs are reviewed in a short meeting with the people in charge of each area.

In that meeting, nobody argues about who is right. You look at the graph. If a line goes up, you find out what made it go up so you can reinforce it. If a line goes down, you find the cause and correct it. If a line stays flat for several weeks, that's also a signal: something has stalled.

Think of a food distributor in Houston. The owner felt that shipping was the bottleneck because he got complaints every week. When he started measuring complete orders delivered on time, he found that shipping was doing its job well and the problem was earlier: orders were coming in entered wrong from sales. Without the number, he would have replaced the wrong person.

The most common mistakes when you start

Many owners try measuring and give up within a month. It's almost always because of one of these mistakes:

  • Measuring too many things at once. Ten indicators per position confuse everyone. Start with one per person.
  • Measuring activity instead of production. "Calls made" is activity; "appointments booked" or "sales closed" is production.
  • Not keeping a graph. A number in a spreadsheet doesn't show the trend. A graph does.
  • Reviewing the numbers only when there are problems. An indicator works when you look at it every week, whether things are going well or badly.
  • Using the numbers to punish. If the team feels the graph is a weapon, they'll dress up the data.

One step you can take this week

Choose a single indicator for your whole company. Ask yourself: if I could only see one number every Friday to know whether my business is doing well, which one would it be? For many businesses it's the money collected that week: not what was invoiced or promised, but what actually came in.

Find that number for the last eight weeks, even if it takes some work, and plot it on graph paper: one week per column, the value on the vertical axis. Connect the dots. What you see in that line will tell you more about your company than many hours of meetings.

From there, the natural question is how to take this to every position and what to do when the line goes up or down. That's exactly what we work on in the Management by Indicators Workshop, a virtual and in-person workshop where you learn to create indicators for each position and to make decisions based on their trends.

← Back to the blog

More posts

Subscribe to our mailing list

Find out about events and new services, we like to keep in touch

Next step

Let's talk about your company

Book an interview with one of our advisors so we can learn about your company's current situation and give you personalized guidance.