You hired someone who had it all in the interview: a good presence, confident answers, experience in the position. Three months later you realized they talked a lot and produced little. Meanwhile, a quieter person, one you almost didn't hire, turned out to be the one holding the whole area together.
A bad hire is one of the most expensive mistakes a small business can make. You don't just pay a salary that doesn't deliver. You also lose customers, overload the rest of the team and, in the end, spend time and money searching all over again. That's why it pays to have a clear criterion before you sit down to interview.
The criterion that matters most: productivity
When you evaluate a candidate, you can look at many things: knowledge, personality, motivation, how easily they follow instructions. They all count. But one weighs more than the rest: productivity, meaning the proven ability to get results.
Think of it this way. If you were looking for someone to cook for an important dinner, it wouldn't be enough for them to know a lot about cooking or to be very pleasant. You'd want to know whether they've made good meals before. It's the same with an employee: the best predictor of what they'll do in your company is what they've already achieved elsewhere.
Some people go to "work" and some people go to produce. The first group focuses on staying busy and completing tasks. The second focuses on the result, takes the initiative and learns on its own whatever it needs. In the interview, your job is to tell one from the other.
What producing means in each position
To look for productivity, you need to know what producing means in the position you want to fill. Some examples:
- In sales, producing means reaching or beating the revenue quota.
- In accounting, it means delivering accurate reports on time.
- In marketing, it means generating enough interested people so sales has someone to talk to.
- In cleaning, it means keeping spaces clean consistently.
- In a restaurant kitchen, it means getting the right dishes out, on time and with the usual quality.
If you've already defined the statistic for that position, the interview gets much easier: you're looking for someone who has moved a similar number in the past.
Questions that reveal productivity
Generic questions, like "What are your strengths?", get rehearsed answers. Questions about concrete results are harder to make up. Some that work well:
What was the result of your work at your last job? Listen for whether they talk about tasks ("I was in charge of...") or results ("I got...").
How did the area or the company change after you arrived? A productive person leaves a mark and can usually describe it in detail.
What did you produce, how much and in how much time? Ask for rough numbers. Not to demand precision, but to see whether the person thinks in terms of production.
How did your production compare with your coworkers'? The answer tells you a lot about how they measure themselves.
Also pay attention to how they answer. A productive person tends to speak in detail, give examples and remember specific situations, because they lived them. Someone who answers in generalities, blames former bosses for everything that went wrong or changes the subject when you ask for an example is giving you valuable information. It's not about distrusting everyone. It's about listening with a clear criterion instead of getting carried away by charm.
If it's a young person with no work experience, ask about achievements at school, in sports or at home: what have you accomplished that you're proud of? Productivity shows early.
Verify before you decide
This is the step people skip most and the one that matters most. After hearing about their achievements, ask: who can I confirm this with? Then make the call.
When you verify, don't ask whether the person was pleasant or punctual. Ask about results: what they produced, how they compared with others, whether they'd hire them again. The owner of an aesthetic clinic in Coral Gables who checks her candidates this way avoids most surprises.
Over time you'll notice that productive people share certain traits: they help others, they commit, they learn fast, they don't go looking for trouble and they have no time for gossip. Someone busy producing is rarely busy criticizing.
A step you can take this week
Before your next interview, write on a card the product of the position you want to fill and the statistic you'll use to measure it. Then prepare three questions about past results and one verification question. Use that card in every interview for the same position, so you compare candidates by the same criterion.
And once you hire, track their statistic from the first week. Finding productive people is the first step; keeping a culture of results is what keeps them productive.
To learn how to evaluate and select the most valuable people for your company, and to tell a valuable team member from one who just sells themselves well, we recommend the Building and Leading Productive Teams Workshop.